Angel and human

Accidentally I placed these two very similar photos of two different models on my two monitors at the same time. And I'm struck the fact that while the pale girl is amazingly pretty, I don't feel much of a connection with her. It does not seem like she is real, like you might meet her and talk with her. She seems too perfect, too angelic.
I think it's a combination of perfect photography (and perhaps retouching), and her facial expression, or lack thereof. Sort of tension-less, no emotion. Whereas the other girl, you can tell that she is thinking, and looking at you.